
Donkey
The Making (and Breaking) of an Ass
Donkey: The Making (and Breaking) of an Ass is Shawn McCraney’s unfiltered autobiographical account of a life shaped by conviction, stubbornness, faith, and repeated humiliation. Tracing his journey from Mormonism to evangelical Christianity and eventually into theological exile, McCraney recounts decades of public ministry, controversy, personal loss, and hard-earned clarity. The title is intentional: a self-aware acknowledgment of the role pride, certainty, and spiritual ambition played in both his rise and his undoing.
Rather than offering a victory story or a defense, Donkey is a confession. McCraney reflects honestly on the cost of speaking publicly about faith, the damage caused by religious systems, and the slow dismantling of his own assumptions about God, truth, and authority. The book is not an argument for a theology so much as a record of being broken by reality and reshaped by humility. It is a story for anyone who has discovered that sincerity does not prevent error, and that clarity often comes after despair.
*Out of limited resources, this book is raw and unedited. We look forward to polishing and editing in the future; for now, enjoy Shawn's unadulterated writing !
Can’t afford it? Contact us and we’ll help you out.
Sample: Introduction: Donkey, The Making of an Ass
When I was ten years of age and living in Mexico, my parents purchased a relatively large parcel of land in a brand-new housing development located in Huntington Beach, California. The nearly quarter acre plot was about a block from the ocean; so close that when the waves got big, we could hear it roar. The foundation for the home hadn’t even been poured when Dad announced that I was going to serve as his apprentice and one day after school we took the first of many drives from Mexico to Huntington, which seemed like it took half a day to even get there.
It didn’t take long for me to understand that what Dad had planned was going to wind up being a herculean undertaking as the land was raw, the house completely unbuilt and my old man thought it necessary to contribute his seed to nearly every stage in its development. As his chosen apprentice, I essentially became the go-to boy for everything that he didn’t want to do – which pretty much exposed me to almost every kind of endeavor imaginable, no matter how dangerous and included nailing, drilling countless holes in the frame (once it was up), pulling wires and he even had me drive, alone, a ten year old donkey over to Goldenwest Street in his truck to pick up loads of manure which were essentially given away in that day by a local mushroom grower. My hooves barely reached the gas pedal but there I was, cruising around a new part of the world behind the giant round black plastic wheel of dad’s old truck.
In addition to these endless chores and tasks, my old man could only be described as being completely obsessed with dirt. Digging in the dirt, shoveling the dirt, roto-tilling the dirt, and moving dirt from one place to the next was something that appeared to make him feel like God. We would grade the dirt endlessly, striving to find the perfect pitch for drainage but again, I was the primary mover of earth he wanted moved as He stood overseeing his creation. Dad had the vision and I did his bidding and by the time I was nearly twelve years of age I became somewhat of a pre-teen expert in moving and managing soil. In digging.
Somedays Dad would have me take wheelbarrows of the stuff to dump across the street to an empty field, other times I was in charge of fortifying the soil with all sorts of additives He deemed necessary including gypsum, sulfur, mulch, fish guts and what seemed like endless truckloads of sand, gravel, and yes, more freaking manure.
Because of our proximity to the ocean, however, there was one activity that forged my character on the anvil of suffering like no other – auguring. What is this auguring? Glad you asked, because I happen to know something about it since I was the toady who was forced to do it (I kid you not) hundreds of times around dad’s personal garden of Eden. Holes – ten inches around and twelve feet deep around my parents’ new home.
See, ol’ Ed (that’s my Dad’s name, may he rest in peace) discovered that due to the closeness of his new home to the beach that the lot upon which it sat was, shall we say, “subject to moisture,” (if you have a positive outlook on life), “saturation” (if you’re an optimist), and plain old flooding if you have the unique ability to see the world as it really is. Apparently, the water table was just too high there and whenever it rained the water from the sky had nowhere to go due to the high levels of water from the sea underground.
Ol’ Ed got the bright idea that he was going to have me stand on my hind legs, put my hooves on this thing, and twist it around and around until hundreds of holes twelve feet deep were created and then, once I hit the sandy sea-water table, he had me fill them back up with gravel so that the water from the sky would have some place to go when it rained.
Without going into a lot of detail, Ole Ed’s strategy was frightfully short-sighted and actually served to bring water into his yard (apparently when the ocean’s tide rose) instead of drawing surface water away. Result? My endless auguring was no different than drilling holes in the bottom of a boat to try and get the water out when any reasonable person would know it was only going to bring more water in. But I digress.
Now, to properly augur, which is also known as post-hole digging (and by the way, there were gas powered augurs around at the time, but they were too expensive to rent according to Ol’ Ed) but to properly augur, the ten-year old donkey starts with a steel pipe that is about three feet in length and has a straight wood handle welded across the top of it that forms what looks like a capital T. Then, at the other end of this pipe the ten-year old had to screw-on a steel-toothed burrowing device. Then said ten-year-old donkey would awkwardly work to screw the tip of the burrowing device into the earth a bit, then lift the T-handle up in both hooves and while pressing down, turn the handle clockwise to get it burrowing. This act would cause the teeth of the toothy steel device to bite into the earth and fill itself with soil. At that point said suffering, swearing ten-year-old donkey would lift the whole device up from the hole, pound the sticky earth from the device’s sharp clutches, and repeat this action until the full first pipe of the augur handle was flush with the ground. At this juncture, the sweating, swearing, wanting-to-hurt-other-animals donkey would unscrew the burrowing head (using a pipe-wrench made in the 1930s), attach another three-foot extension to the first section of pipe, rethread the burrowing head back on the extended end, and repeat until his mother-freaking-son of a red-tongued-demon was about twelve feet in length. That’s how deep ole Ed wanted each core to be. Not one inch less.
Then the child, hands blistered, legs caked with sea-mud, and one-in-spirit you’re your standard third-world donkeys, would have to load a creaky-steel-rusted wheelbarrow with a wobbly solid rubber tire full of various grades of gravel, push it over hills of manure, and fill the hole back up to the brim.
Hundreds of them. Get the picture?
Here’s the deal with auguring. When the teeth of the burrowing device hit an obstacle large enough to impede its progress downward, like an old can, asphalt or worst of all a rock, the augur teeth will just spin upon its surface making no progress downward. Sometimes the donkey would hit a rock within the first foot or two down which was frustrating but manageable but at other times said boulders would present themselves five feet, seven feet or even eleven feet down which would bring the donkey child to braying and kicking into the air out of sheer frustration. Then the screaming, gnashing, thrashing, rock-throwing ten-year-old donkey was repeatedly instructed that it was up to him to figure out how to proceed. And Ol’ Ed would check - every single hole – to make certain I had done my job.
The obstacles caused the ten-year-old donkey to invent and employ various inventive practices in his attempts at dislodging whatever it was that hindered his progress downward. Everything was difficult, but the rocks were the worst, especially if they were larger than the augur hole itself!
Sometimes he would have to attach a long steel bar using steel wire to the end of the auger head then ram the device down into the hole with all of his might to try to break or dislodge whatever obstacle stood in his way. Sometimes one obstacle took him half the day to move, remove or destroy. Sometimes he dreamed of killing himself.
But most of the time he daydreamed of being back in Mexico, hanging out with his friends, and listening to his older brother’s albums when he wasn’t home. Great albums from Cream, Jethro Tull, and Black Sabbath.
Fortunately, I was given a large transistor radio for my eleventh birthday which went with me everywhere but I made sure it was out there on the dirt with me adding a score to my personal sufferings.
The music scene was weird back in the early 70s. There was a general genre where everything sounded the same, like
“I’ll Take You There” by the Staple Singers
“Daddy Don't You Walk So Fast” by Wayne Newton
“Brandy” by Looking Glass
and “Lean on Me” by Bill Withers
(plus some other personal favorites like, “It's So Nice to Be With You,” by Gallery, “Backstabbers” by the O'Jays, and “Papa was a Rollin Stone” by the Temptations – not to mention anything by Elton John). But there were other songs that would pop out from the airwaves that served to weave a new thread of sound in the tapestry of my personal discography, including,
“Rock and Roll” by Gary Glitter
“School's Out” by Alice Cooper
“Metal Guru” by T. Rex
These tunes brought a magic to my mind out there under the hot Southern California sun and little did I realize how I was formulating my world view from the smell of the sea, the dirt on my skin and the courageous vibrations of the daring. All of this became a soundtrack in my memories of becoming what I am.
By the time I was closing in on thirteen, however, I started to balk and buck at Ol’ Ed’s demands. I would see kids riding their bikes with carefree abandon to the beach and knew that I was trapped in the despotic clutches of an insane dirt devil. We argued, literally went to war at times, but Ole Ed was relentless, and I wasn’t able to escape his reign until I started swimming competitively in the summer before my freshman year of high school.
Looking back, however, I now see the favor Ole Ed had given his son because by and through these years of torture, I not only learned to dig but I learned to relentlessly go to war against any and every obstacle that stood in the way of my getting to my desired destination.
No matter the pain, no matter the cost.