
Knife To A Gunfight
Misinterpreting The Purpose and Place of the New Testament
"Knife To A Gunfight" by Shawn McCraney is a concise and synthesized argument against the misapplied role of scripture and authority in the faith. McCraney comprehensively challenges traditional views and encourages believers to embrace a faith in Christ that is free from unnecessary traditions. The book serves as both an argument and an invitation to rethink what it truly means to follow Jesus.
Sample: An Admission
When it comes to teaching and sharing insights about the Word of God every presenter has to ask themselves, “Will I focus on and promote false hope or will I choose to promote unadulterated truth?” Promoting hope builds religious empires; presenting truth comes at a very high price.
We know that Jesus came to earth to bring a message of hope. But had He made hope His primary message He would have fulfilled the desires of those around Him by being a Messiah who would deliver the Jews from Roman bondage and rule. Focusing on truth, Jesus explained that the emancipation He provided would liberate them from sin and death – a message of truth that did not meet their hopeful expectations. Of course, He was rejected. In this we clearly see that Jesus placed teaching truth over perpetuating false hope - a demand that remains upon all pastors and teachers today.
As a self-described and self-appointed pastor/teacher I have to constantly seek to rightfully balance preaching and teaching Jesus (and Him alone) as our hope while never backing away from the painful realities present in a contextual view of the Bible. For example, where many believers today want to continue to believe in miracles (like those that were performed in Jesus' day), I tend to suggest that those miracles were pictures of the spiritual healing Jesus would continue to perform after that age; that the greatest miracle of our age is when a dead, sinful heart comes to life through faith in Him.
Likewise, Christians today tend to hope that Jesus is coming back to rapture and save them from this evil world. And while I accept all believers' views on end times and refuse to separate or castigate anyone for these respective stances, I also refuse to teach this “message of hope” when the Bible clearly (in a contextual sense) proves otherwise.
This truth, however, tends to strip the hope believers have in His eminent return – a hope, in my estimation, that was false from the get go and is actually based on hope in an "event" that Jesus will bring, rather than in Jesus Himself. And the list goes on and on.
I am convinced that those who love and/or embrace false messages of hope (over the painful truth) “have their reward.” Even if the falsehoods in and of themselves appear harmless. In other words, if a lie serves to uplift and support a believer in their walk with Christ through this world I tend to believe that the lie will have served its purpose - but since it is of this world, in the world to come it will carry no weight.
God seeks those who seek Him in Spirit and in truth. If the truth takes a backseat to false messages of hope I can’t help but believe that there will be cost – not in terms of punishment but of eternal reward.
Why my insistence in presenting hard, contextual, biblical truths over promoting (false) hope? I am convinced that God created me in such a way (through nurture and nature), and that I cannot help but seek to know, teach, and promote truth over everything else – no matter how painful or how high the cost is for the instruction. Don’t get me wrong. I’m not suggesting that I am an honest man. I have – and continue to – lie, mostly as a means to escape discovery or scrutiny for things I want to remain obscured. I don’t like this about myself (nor excuse it), and though I try hard to be an honest man in all things I am not above telling a lie to escape pain or discovery.
That being said, I am ardent in seeking and teaching all truths about God, religions that claim to speak for Him, churches that bear His name, community, politics, corporations, systems, philosophies – whatever - as openly and as transparently as possible – no matter what the fallout or cost might be.
I was born charming and affable. More as a means to survive and get my way then out of love for others. As the middle child of six I was a natural peacemaker who sought to please and make friends wherever they could be found. Over the course of time and through experiences I found traumatic to my person, I discovered that the world, and its systems, institutions (and the people who support them), could not be taken at face value, and therefore could not to be trusted. Would I manipulate and charm them? Certainly. This was part of my nature. But I never trusted any of them.
These seeds of mistrust may have come from my parents who, trying to raise their family upright and strong, could only show conditional approval of me rather than an unconditional acceptance. I learned that in order to be praised and accepted by Mom and Dad, I had to comply and conform to their expectations and opinions of things – to do otherwise produced alienation and reproach. In my mind, this system could not be trusted or confided in in any meaningful way, and so my relationship to them was in many ways perfunctory. I don’t blame them or hold any sort of grudge for this approach. They did their best and provided many wonderful things for me out of unconditional love and acceptance. But an environment of complete openness was not encouraged nor rewarded, and so I saw it as faulty.
The same was true of organized religion. In every situation, from my LDS upbringing to my conversion to Christianity and attendance at Calvary Chapels, there was never an environment of unconditional acceptance (of lifestyle, thought, expression or truth), but there were always demands for compliance, conformity, and allegiance to culture, tradition, established doctrines and practices. Something is still wrong, I would think, and I could not allow myself to play a real part of any system that refused open dialogue, freedom of thought, and opinions that challenged the status quo. And so I never really belonged. The same was true of Evangelical Christianity writ large – or of any religious institution. To me they were all out to serve themselves, and their teachings, doctrines, and view of scripture proved it.
It goes without saying that commercial corporations were no different in my eyes and that they too (as do organizations of every ilk) have their ways, tried and true - and to differ or challenge them was anathema to the established order. And so I was never going to fit the corporate model of things – and never could. In the end, there was nothing under the sun that would or could fulfill my desire for unconditional love, the freedom to search and challenge, the ability to see and think as I was lead – except one. The Lord and Savior Jesus Christ.
In Him I discovered total and unconditional acceptance - received through faith – of my person, personality, ideas, failures and perspectives. In Him there is complete and total safety. Not in ideas about Him. Not in theories concerning Him. Not in doctrines or disputable matters orbiting around Him. Just in Him.
In the case of “Jesus alone” I was willing, because of who He is and His unfailing love and unconditional heart for me, to place my utter and complete faith, hope and allegiance in and upon Him. He is true. He never disappoints. He does not force. He is not self-serving. He is not hypocritical. He does not ostracize over failures or rambling thoughts. He understands rebellion, challenge, seeking. He is the Rock. Immovable. Sure. Complete. Unchanging. Him and Him alone.
By and through this direct relationship with Him I have been able to stand against errant traditions, false religions, insipid interpretations, and long established orthodoxy that have forever gone unchallenged, but are routinely promoted by keepers of tradition and the status quo. Please know I do not challenge for challenge's sake. I actually abhor upsetting the apple cart and seek for peace and unity among all the faithful. But I cannot help but “see” failures where they reside, and am driven to expose any untruth, no matter how much false hope is destroyed, in the process. May God forgive me where I am wrong.