
Don't F**k With God
A Part of the Don't F**k With Series
The book "Don't F**k With God" by Shawn McCraney aims to dismantle the numerous misconceptions about God's nature, often perpetuated by traditional religious structures. Using the Yeshuan biblical perspective to articulate the ontology and nature of God, it ultimately emphasizes that God's love is unconditional and not contingent on human obedience, countering the portrayal of God as vengeful. The book explores the misuse of God's name, distortions of His nature, and misconceptions about His omnipotence, advocating for a clearer understanding of God beyond the perpetuated myths of modern Christianity.
Can’t afford it? Contact us and we’ll help you out.
Sample: F**king With His Make-Up
General Christianity as a whole, influenced by Roman Catholicism and its creedal devotions, mindlessly endorses a man-made term to describe the Living God, called YHWH, through the name or title of “the Trinity.”
This is the biggest bit of f**kery to ever come down the pike of Christianity. But understand clearly and right out of the gate, this does NOT mean that Jesus wasn’t God with us, or that the Holy Spirit is not God reaching to us. Unwilling to deal with the nuances of uncertainty, early Christian men put in positions of influence congregated and devised or fashioned the Golden calf of Christianity, the Trinity.
In direct response to the incomprehensibility of this man-made-male Chimera, Joseph Smith Jr., founder of Mormonism, created a fiction about God in a revamped history called the first vision, which over time morphed into a grand myth of its own saying that God, still thriving in a body of flesh and bone, was actually once a man! Talk about F**king with the make-up of God! But let’s go back to what lead Smith to create his own fictional description of God and the major irritant appears to be what are called, creeds.
To make it simple, the nascent Christian Church had Jesus, and then His apostles. They were killed off and never replaced. Of course, men, refusing to see that this was purposeful to God and how He would govern His true body of believers through His Spirit, decided to try and bring the faith forward through the ages in an orderly and therefore demanded and agreed-upon fashion.
These men quickly realized that to do this effectively, and as a means to wrangled people into a cohesive collective they had to effectively systematize everything about the faith – its doctrines, practices, and beliefs – and this was especially true relative to the nature of God.
See, some believers rose up in that post destruction of Jerusalem and started teaching the ideas that were contrary to the established order or the most popular views of believers at that time. These views troubled those seeking power and as a means to offset the ensuing chaos that individualism innately creates, men gathered together and formalized Christian doctrine and practice into statements of faith, also known as Creeds. Let’s quickly look at the evolution of some of the earliest and most lasting creeds beginning with what is called, The Apostles Creed (even though the Apostles were long dead when it was created). The Apostles Creed says
I believe in God the Father Almighty, Maker of heaven and earth. And in Jesus Christ, His only Son, our Lord; Who was conceived by the Holy Spirit; Born of the Virgin Mary; Suffered under Pontius Pilate; Was crucified, dead and buried; He descended into Hell; The third day He rose again from the dead; He ascended into heaven; And sitteth on the right hand of God the Father Almighty; From thence He shall come to judge the living and the dead. I believe in the Holy Spirit; The Holy Christian Church, the Communion of Saints; The Forgiveness of sins; The Resurrection of the body; And the life everlasting. Amen.
This was believed to have been composed somewhere between 120AD and 250AD and was apparently an “official” response to the teachings of a man named, Marcion, who was a Christian, but taught a different view of God than the commonly accepted one. Interestingly, Marcion believed he was following the teaching of Paul.
The Apostles Creed isn’t all to bad – although it is a creed and does choose to summarize some things that I believe are subject to interpretation (for instance, I believe in . . . the Holy Christian Church, the Communion of Saints; The Forgiveness of sins; The Resurrection of the body) but we will leave the criticism of this for another book. Bottom line, this initial creed isn’t all too offensive.
The second major Creed is called, the Creed of Nicaea (or Nicaean Creed) and it was composed in 325AD by a “councel of men” who were trying to solve what was deemed, “the Arian controversy.” The Arian controversy was a series of Christian disputes about the nature of Christ that began when two men, Arius and Athanasius, both of Alexandria, Egypt, disagreed with each other. Read about it sometime, it’s really interesting. In any case, the end result was the Nicaean Creed which says:
We believe in one God, the father almighty, Maker of heaven and earth, and of all things visible and invisible. And in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father, Light of light, Very God of very God, begotten not made, being of one substance with the Father; by whom all things were made; who for us men, and for our salvation, came down from heaven, and was incarnate and was made man; He suffered, and the third day he rose again, ascended into heaven, from there He shall come to judge both the quick and the dead; and in the Holy Spirit.
Note that it says . . .
(speaking of Jesus) “begotten of the Father before all ages, God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten not made, being of one substance with the Father, through Whom all things were made: Who for us men and for our salvation came down from heaven, was incarnate by the Holy Spirit of the virgin Mary, and was made man.”
(and note in reference to Jesus return it says that he) ”ascended into heaven, and from there He shall come . . . . not “has come,” as the scripture and secular history reports, “but shall.” (see, Don’t F**K with Jesus by this same author).
The third major Creed was composed fifty-six years later (381AD) in Nicaea and serves as an expansion and revision of the 325 Creed of Nicaea. This is the most widely accepted Christian creed today and it is a direct critique of something called apollinarism and in a later addition, of something that has come to be known as the Filioque clause. Interestingly enough, this later addition resulted in disagreement between Eastern Christianity and Western Christianity and served to help create a schism between Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxies who ultimately divided in AD 1054. Here is what it says:
I believe in one God, the Father almighty, maker of heaven and earth and of all things visible and invisible. And in one Lord Jesus Christ, the only-begotten Son of God, begotten of the Father before all ages, God of God, Light of Light, very God of very God, begotten not made, being of one substance with the Father, through Whom all things were made: Who for us men and for our salvation came down from heaven, was incarnate by the Holy Spirit of the virgin Mary, and was made man: Who for us, too, was crucified under Pontius Pilate, suffered, and was buried: the third day He rose according to the Scriptures, ascended into heaven, and is seated on the right hand of the Father: He shall come again with glory to judge the living and the dead, and His kingdom shall have no end. And in the Holy Spirit, the Lord and Giver of life, Who proceeds from the Father and the Son: Who together with the Father and the Son is worshiped and glorified: Who spoke by the prophets. And I believe one holy, Christian, and apostolic Church. I acknowledge one baptism for the remission of sins, and I look for the resurrection of the dead and life of the age to come. Amen.
Did you catch the subtle enhancements that are included in this document created approximately 145 after the Apostles Creed and fifty-six years after the first Nicaean Creed? They include the lines:
(and speaking of a Second Coming says) “He shall come again with glory”
(and speaking of the Holy Spirit adds) “Who together with the Father and the Son is worshiped and glorified”
(and then speaking of Christian practice, says) “And I believe one holy, Christian, and apostolic Church. I acknowledge one baptism for the remission of sins . . .”
Carefully consider these “additions” as they directly reveal the desire of men to control the minds and hearts of all who seek God and His Son in spirit and truth.
In 451 the Catholic church created the fourth major Christian Creed (the Chalcedonian Creed) which was in response to what is known as Nestorian teachings. It was here that Jesus is described as having “two natures", which "come together into one person and one hypostasis". Because of this Creed most Modern Christians readily and thoughtlessly describe Jesus as “being 100% Man and 100% God” (does that make any sense to you?) and unfortunately this depiction is accepted by nearly all Christian denominations (except Oriental Orthodoxy, the Assyrian Church of the East, and much of those churches that are part of the Restorationist movement).
Here is that little gem:
We, then, following the holy Fathers, all with one consent, teach men to confess one and the same Son, our Lord Jesus Christ, the same perfect in Godhead and also perfect in manhood; truly God and truly man, of a reasonable soul and body; consubstantial with us according to the manhood; in all things like unto us, without sin; begotten before all ages of the Father according to the Godhead, and in these latter days, for us and for our salvation, born of the virgin Mary, the mother of God, according to the manhood; one and the same Christ, Son, Lord, Only-begotten, to be acknowledged in two natures, inconfusedly, unchangeably, indivisibly, inseparably; the distinction of natures being by no means taken away by the union, but rather the property of each nature being preserved, and concurring in one Person and one Subsistence, not parted or divided into two persons, but one and the same Son, and only begotten, God the Word, the Lord Jesus Christ, as the prophets from the beginning have declared concerning him, and the Lord Jesus Christ himself taught us, and the Creed of the holy Fathers has handed down to us.
Sound reasonable to you? Make sense? Or are you discovering that Jesus is becoming more and more incomprehensible along with God Himself?
Finally, we come to the fifth major Creed established by Man. It’s called the Athanasian Creed, which is regarded as authoritative in the Roman Catholic church and in some Protestant denominations.
It has two sections, one dealing with the Trinity and the other with the Incarnation of the Word; and it begins and ends with stern warnings that devotion to these stances are indispensable to salvation.
The virulence of these damnatory clauses has led some critics, especially in the Anglican churches, to secure restriction or abandonment of the use of the creed.
The author is unknown but suspected. Now get a load of this one:
And the Catholic Faith is this: that we worship One God in Trinity, and Trinity in Unity; neither confounding the Persons nor dividing the substance. For there is one person of the Father, another of the Son, and another of the Holy Ghost. But the Godhead of the Father, of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost, is all one; the glory equal, the majesty co-eternal. Such as the Father is, such is the Son, and such is the Holy Ghost, the Father uncreate, the son uncreate, and the Holy Ghost uncreate; the Father eternal, the Son eternal, and the Holy Ghost eternal; and yet they are not three eternals, but one eternal. As also there are not three incomprehensibles, nor three uncreated, but one uncreated, and one incomprehensible. So likewise the Father is Almighty, the Son Almighty, and the Holy Ghost Almighty; and yet they are not three Almighties, but one Almighty. So the Father is God, the Son is God, and the Holy Ghost is God; and yet they are not three Gods, but one God. So likewise the Father is Lord, the Son Lord, and the Holy Ghost Lord; and yet not three Lords, but one Lord. For like as we are compelled by the Christian verity to acknowledge every person by himself to be God and Lord; so we are forbidden by the Catholic religion to say, There be three Gods, or three Lords. The Father is made of none, neither created nor begotten. The Son is of the Father alone, not made nor created, but begotten. The Holy Ghost is of the Father and of the Son; neither made nor created nor begotten, but proceeding. So there is one Father, not three Fathers; one Son, not three Sons; one Holy Ghost, not three Holy Ghosts. And in this Trinity none is afore or after another, none is greater or less than another; but the whole three persons are co-eternal together, and co-equal. So that in all things, as is aforesaid, the Unity in Trinity, and the Trinity in Unity, is to be worshipped. He, therefore, that will be saved, must thus think of the Trinity.
Furthermore, it is necessary to everlasting salvation, that he also believe rightly the incarnation of our Lord Jesus Christ. For the right faith is, that we believe and confess that our Lord Jesus Christ, the Son of God, is God and man; God of the substance of the Father, begotten before the worlds; and man, of the substance of his mother, born in the world; perfect God, and perfect man; of a reasonable soul and human flesh subsisting; equal to the Father, as touching his Godhead; and inferior to the Father, as touching his manhood; who, although he be God and man, yet is he not two, but one Christ; one, not by conversion of the Godhead into flesh, but by taking of the manhood into God. One altogether, not by confusion of substance, but by unity of person. For as the reasonable soul and flesh is one man, so God and man is one Christ: who suffered for our salvation; descended into hell, rose again the third day from the dead; he ascended into heaven, he sitteth on the right hand of the Father, God Almighty, from whence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead; at whose coming all men shall rise again with their bodies, and shall give account for their own works. And they that have done good shall go into life everlasting; and they that have done evil, into everlasting fire. This is the Catholic faith, which except a man believe faithfully, he cannot be saved. Glory be to the Father and to the Son, and to the Holy Ghost. As it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be, world without end. Amen.
The point? Christianity – since the last living apostle took his final breath – has been a growing amalgam of revisions, changes and manipulations which have all served to obscure the simple biblically supported truths about the nature of God (along with a host of other things). So relative to the man-made doctrine of the Trinity, ask yourselves something:
Do you think the (so-called) Christian doctrine of the Trinity reflect more of the Jewish view of God (which is clearly monotheistic) or that of the Greeks (and other pagan cultures (which were clearly polytheistic)?
Reread the Great Shema. And ask yourself this question again. See, we all read the same Bible, the same verses, the same context – and clearly from the Judeo Christian biblical perspective, there is only one God, right?
So again, do you think the doctrine of Trinity best reflects Judaism, the forerunner to Christianity, or the polytheistic views of paganism? Many historians (and Bible scholars too) agree that the Christian idea of Trinity owes far more to Greek philosophy (and its predecessor, pagan polytheism) than to the monotheism of the Jew and what came from the mouth of the Jewish Jesus.
4000 years ago, the ancient Sumerian culture had their own trinity. And even though Sumeria was overcome by the Assyrians and the Babylonians, their views of a triune god carried on over the ages. One historian named S. H. Hooke describes the Sumerian trinity in his book Babylonian and Assyrian Religion, saying:
Anu was the primary god of heaven, the ‘Father’, and the ‘King of the Gods;’ Enlil, the ‘wind-god’ was the god of the earth, and a creator god; and Enki was the god of waters and the ‘lord of wisdom’ (15-18). So, Anu, Enlil, and Enki. This trinity god pushed then into Babylonia (and another historian - H. Saggs) writes that the Babylonian triad consisted of ‘three gods of roughly equal rank... whose inter-relationship is of the essence of their natures’.
Another author, Alexander Hislop in his book, “The Two Babylons: or, the Papal Worship,” describes the Babylonian triune God, by saying
‘In the unity of that one Only God of the Babylonians there were three persons, and to symbolize [sic] that doctrine of the Trinity, they employed... the equilateral triangle, just as it is well known the Romish Church does at this day’
Looking to Egypt, they anciently believed in a God named Amun. But according to George Hart, lecturer for the British Museum and professor of ancient Egyptian heiroglyphics at the University of London, Amun was really three gods in one. He describes them as
Amun was the hidden god
Re was his face, and
Ptah his body
Speaking of this god, the great historian Will Durant, in his book Oriental Heritage (page 201) says that Ra, Amon, and Ptah were, “combined as three embodiments or aspects of one supreme and triune deity.” And Hornung, in his book, Conceptions of God in Ancient Egypt: The One and the Many, presents a hymn to Amun (the hidden God) which was written fourteen hundred years before the birth of the Messiah. These ancient lyrics say:
‘All Gods are three: Amun, Re, Ptah; they have no equal. His name is hidden as Amun, he is Re... before [men], and his body is Ptah’
(from, Conceptions of God in Ancient Egypt: The One and the Many. Trans. John Baines. Ithaca: Cornell UP. 1982).
What do experts think about all of this preface material to the council of Nicaea’s decision to adopt the concept of a Trinity too? Will Durant wrote in his epic book Caesar the following, ‘from Egypt came the ideas of a divine trinity...’ (Caesar 595).
And one Dr. Gordon Laing, retired Dean of the Humanities Department at the University of Chicago, agrees, writing that
“‘the worship of the Egyptian triad Isis, Serapis, and the child Horus’ probably accustomed the early church theologians to the idea of a triune God, and was influential ‘in the formulation of the doctrine of the Trinity as set forth in the Nicaean and Athanasian creeds’ (Laing, Gordon Jennings. Survivals of Roman Religion. New York: Cooper Square Publishers. 1963, page 128-129).
I do not think that Jesus was just chatting with the Samaritan woman at the well when he said:
“But the time comes, and now is, when the true worshippers shall worship the Father in spirit and in truth; for the Father seeks such to worship Him.”
Let’s look at a few more examples of early influences that could have contributed to the man-made notion of Trinity. There was a group known as the Etruscans that passed from Babylon through Greece and then went on into Rome. Guess what they brought with them? That’s right, their own ideas of a triune god!
See, the Etruscans trinity consisted of Tinia, Uni, and Menerva. This novel idea was unheard of to the Romans, but it didn’t take long for them to adopt it. Before long this “three in one god” idea became so ‘typical of Rome’ that it quickly spread throughout Italy. Even the names of this “Roman trinity” - Jupiter, Juno, and Minerva - reflect their origin. Did Catholic Christianity borrow from these influences in its construction of its Trinity? Again, historian Will Durrant had thoughts on this, saying:
“Christianity did not destroy paganism; it adopted it.” (Caesar 595).
Listen to what the Catholic Pope Gregory I said to his missionaries around 600 AD:
‘You must not interfere with any traditional belief or religious observance that can be harmonized with Christianity.’
Now, one of the single most distinguishing facts about true ancient Judaism was its absolute refusal to embrace anything that smacked of pagan polytheism. Listen to just a few Old Testament passages that endorse their devotion to the One God (whom Paul calls the Father):
“Hear O Israel, the Lord our God is one Lord.” (And)
“before Me there was no God formed, Neither shall any be after Me.” (Isaiah 43:10) (and)
“there is no other God...I am the LORD and there is none else.” (Isaiah 45:14,18)
In light of these simple verses (and a whole lot more)I think we can safely conclude without much difficulty that the concept of the Trinity did not come from Judaism. Judaism is monotheistic. And genuine Christianity, is strictly monotheistic as well; strictly in the sense that there is one God, the Father.
So why has this Trinity been so ubiquitously received and reiterated today? Really, really think about this:
We embrace, recite, and teach a man-made term (Trinity) to describe the Living God! And many Christian apologists (let alone the mass of believers) will flat out reject anyone as saved who dares question this quixotic tradition!
I read the same Bible as these apologists. I see Jesus as the author and finisher of my faith. I believe He is God with us, that there is one God, but if I reject this non-biblical man-made, pagan-based term “trinity” I am at best challenged and at worst maligned as a heretic?
Ever wonder why God Himself didn’t plainly explain Himself in Trinitarian terms so those who love and seek Him could have a plain understanding directly from Him that He is
one God who eternally exists as three distinct persons — the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
Re-read that accepted definition carefully. Read it again. Re-read the part about this one God “eternally existing as three distinct persons.” And think about that for a minute.
(this space was intentionally left blank to enhance your contemplation – to remind you to really think past what you have been taught)
Okay, hear me clearly – plainly – as I reiterate something really important here:
Most critics of the Trinity take the position that Jesus was NOT God. Again, I do not take this position. Additionally, most people who agree that Jesus is God (but reject the trinity) preach what has been pejoratively deemed modalism (or Sabellianism). Again, not here! I am not suggesting that the Father became the Son, and that the Son became the Holy Spirit!
Do I believe that there is the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit at work in the redemption of Man? Absolutely.
Do I believe that the Father is God? Yes.
Do I believe that the Son is God? Yes.
The Holy Spirit? Yes.
Do I believe there is only One God? Yes.
So, isn’t this the Trinity? No! It’s not!
It might be what you believe the Trinity to be – but you would be wrong. It might also be the clear picture the Bible paints, which I once believed to be the Trinity – but I was wrong too!
Bottom-line (and we’ll flesh this out down the road) but bottom line, we have one God named YHWH and He is one. He is not three persons. He is one God. He has always and forever been only one God. This is a God that a monotheist would worship. And this One God has manifested Himself in all sorts of means and ways to human beings over the millennia. This is the One God whom Jesus refers to the Samaritan woman as the Father.
He has appeared as fire.
He has spoken as a still small voice.
He has manifested Himself in clouds, and smoke and wind, and in an assortment of other ways.
Were they all God? Yes. All manifestations of One God? Yes! Were they manifestations of more than one God? No.
Did this God manifest Himself in spirit? Yes! The second verse in the first chapter of Genesis makes this clear, saying:
“And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters.”
Did this single monotheistic God also manifest Himself in . . . flesh? He did! How? His very Word (logos) was made flesh and dwelled among us. In fact, Jesus said it plainly to Philip:
“If you have seen me, you’ve seen the father.”
The Greek word for “see” in this passage is horao and is better understood as Jesus saying:
“If you have discerned me, Philip, (and not literally seen me which is the Greek word blepo) you have seen the Father.”
And this is all I am suggesting. The Spirit was God. From God, of God, and just God. His Spirit. What was in Jesus? God. From God, of God, and just God, in flesh. Where was God when He manifested Himself in all of these ways? In one location – His heavenly home. And it is all really no more complicated than this -
God is one who manifests Himself in a bunch of different ways. He is NOT three persons, separate and distinct as Larry, Moe and Curley. If the manifestation is from God, then the manifestation is God, and is sent by the One God to teach us and to reveal Himself to us.
So where did all this stuff about “three persons, co-equal, co-eternal, uncreated which comprise the one true God” come from which plainly bastardize the nature of the true and living God? From men who needed to control the doctrine so they could then control the masses.
In his ministry, Jesus was all over the concept that He was there to do the will of God (His Father). In terms of His relationship with the Father He said,
“... I seek not mine own will, but the will of the Father which hath sent me,” John 5:30.
In John 7:16 He said “my doctrine is not mine, but His that sent me.”
Remember what He said in John 14:28?
“my Father is greater than I.”
How could His Father be greater if they are co-equal, co-eternal, equal angles of a triangle? The man of Nazareth was certainly co-equal by virtue of what was in Him, which was God. But His flesh was anything but co-equal, or co-eternal. His flesh was human.
The Trinity does not allow for this – unless some real mental gymnastics are allowed. But let’s step back a little. Let’s start out a little slower. Nowhere in the Bible is the Trinity mentioned. It, like the doctrine it promotes, is man-made along with all of its definitions.
Defenders of the Trinity myth will respond to this by pointing out that nowhere in the Bible is atheism, rapture, omniscience, divinity, incarnation or monotheism mentioned – but the Bible clearly supports their meaning. I maintain that the Bible is clear on who God is, however, and to cobble some word to describe him is akin to other phony man-made religious terms like, “slain in the spirit,” “daily devotionals,” “Mariology,” or “second coming.”
To more clearly find the origins of the Trinity in Christianity, we need to take a look at the circumstances in which early Christians found themselves.
Very early on in church history, even in the days of the apostles, there was corruption afloat. The Apostle Paul said in his epistle to the Thessalonians (2nd Thessalonians 2:7) that “the mystery of iniquity doth already work.”
Throughout his book, Orthodoxy and Heresy in Earliest Christianity, the German New Testament scholar, lexicographer, and early Church historian, Walter Bauer, effectively proves that many early Christians were influenced by a movement called, Gnosticism.
In his work, “The Greek Fathers,” James Marshall Campbell, a Greek professor, speaks of how prevalent Gnosticism was in the early church – and it was so prevalent that many of the apostle’s writings were to try and dissuade believers from adopting its ways. What, exactly, did the Gnostics believe?
Gnosticism borrowed much of its philosophy and religion from something called Mithraism, oriental mysticism, astrology, actual magic, and Plato. It considered matter to be evil and in opposition to Deity, relied heavily on visions, and sought salvation through knowledge, not faith.
The late Professor Arthur Cushman McGiffert, in his book, “A history of Christian Thought,” says some of the early Christian fathers saw Gnosticism as ‘identical in all intents and purposes with Greek polytheism.’ (As an aside, where many Christian apologists herald the Patristic Fathers as devoted bearers of Christian light I tend to see them all as failing – no maliciously or with evil intent, but not one of them escapes propagating some extra-biblical myth or another and collectively they best represent the gates of hell beginning to prevail against the church and not proof of protecting it.)
As with most things, Gnosticism had a mixed influence on the early Christian writers - some were influenced by Gnostic thought and blended elements of it into Christianity while others swung to the opposite extreme and fought against all of it passionately, which included warfare against the acquisition of knowledge, which, as stated, was a major focus Gnostic thought. But here’s the deal – thinkers are thinkers – and such are typically swayed (intellectually) by intellectual concepts. J. N. D. Kelly, lecturer and principal at St. Edward Hall, Oxford University, said that
“the concepts of philosophy provided thinkers... with an intellectual framework for expressing their ideas to the extent that it became the ‘deeper religion of most intelligent people.”
In other words, Greek philosophy and culture began to factor into the formation of Christian thought. The philosophical concepts prevalent during the time of the early church were Stoicism, which, according to McGiffert was ‘ethical in its interests and monistic in its ontology,’ and Platonism, which was ‘dualistic and predominately religious.’
It is a historical fact that these philosophies affected Christianity – at least culturally. But what did these philosophers teach about God? In Plato’s work, Timeus, his “supreme reality” is a trinitarian form of
the Good,
the Intelligence,
and the World-Soul.
Author Kenneth Laing attributes elaborate Trinitarian theories to the Neoplatonists, and considers Neoplatonic ideas as ‘one of the operative factors in the development of Christian theology.’
These factors support the thesis that early Christian ideas on the Trinity did in fact descend from Greek philosophy. Not proofs, but the stuff does add up and help make a case.
Will Durant tied Greek philosophy to Christianity when he wrote that the second century Alexandrian Church, (from which both Clement and Origen came) ‘wedded Christianity to Greek philosophy’ and that, speaking of the famed pagan Philosopher Plotinus, said ‘Christianity accepted nearly every line of it ....’
So, what happened in the formation of this man-made, non-biblical hogwash called, the Holy Trinity? Let me appeal to Durrant one more time, as he puts it so well:
“In Christ and Peter, Christianity was Jewish; in Paul it became half Greek; in Catholicism it became half Roman.”
I call that a f**king monster.
Let’s continue on with some scripture now. In John 8:12 we read:
Then spake Jesus again unto them, saying, “I am the light of the world: he that followeth me shall not walk in darkness, but shall have the light of life.”
Let’s focus on the first line of this passage – where Jesus says, “I am the Light of the World.” This might take a couple pages.
The first thing we have to note is in response to this statement the attending Pharisees did NOT rent their clothing nor seek out stones to kill Him. How come?
“I am the light of the world” is a very bold statement, is it not? To me, and in this day and age, it almost sounds like one of the most incendiary statements a person could make about themselves – sort of like saying, “I am God” right? But interestingly the Jews response to it was sort of like, “yeah, yeah, yeah, you’re just singing your own praises, just testifying of yourself.”
According to German Bible scholar Johann Schoettgen, who specialized in Hebrew Messianism, there was a commonly held belief that the promised Messiah would be “a light to the world.” So, where on earth did the Jews get this idea from? Let’s see how they responded to Jesus when He said this about himself. They said:
“Thou bearest record of thyself; thy record is not true,” (and which we will cover in greater detail later) and this was really their way of saying, “you’re not the promised Messiah, so stop testifying of yourself.”
This is the first point we want to understand about this beautiful line uttered by Jesus – the Jews were neither surprised nor offended by it – they rejected it, but were not offended by it, like they were when He later says, “before Abraham was, I Am.”
The main argument I have against the man-made doctrine of the Trinity it that it has been classically defined as The Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit existing as separate persons, or minds or core essences) PRIOR to creation.
In other words, Trinitarian doctrine maintains that if we were to have the ability to see God in His state before the creation of anything, we would see THREE SEPARATE AND DISTINCT PERSONS standing there. And we would exclaim, “O look, there is the One God!”
No (effin) way.
There are two general (but acceptable) views within Christianity relative to this definition of Trinity. One says that the Son, Jesus Christ, has existed as the Son for eternity. This is known as Eternal Sonship. The other is that the Word of God (which was the Son prior to taking on a body of flesh and being called Jesus) existed as a separate person or being eternally but was utterly and absolutely distinct from the Father.
I more closely adhere to this later perspective primarily because nowhere in the Old Testament descriptions of God is God described as either being (or being in) a Father/Son relationship.
In other words, I reject eternal Sonship completely and believe the pre-incarnate state of what would become the man Jesus of Nazareth is better understood as “the Word” of the one living God, and with the Holy Spirit being the breath (or ruach/pneuma) of the same, and with God not becoming a literal Father until His very word was made flesh and dwelled among us.
However, and additionally, I also maintain that neither the Word of God nor the Spirit of God were separate and distinct individual persons from the One God who is ultimately called, the Father. No way. And this is my wholesale rejection of the Trinity – it takes three persons, calls them separate, distinct, co-equal, uncreated and in the end, the One God.
Again, and for clarifications sake, Orthodox Christianity has long taught and believed the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit existed in the beginning, as persons individuated (before the foundations of the world) and they are respectively known as the eternal persons of the One God called Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. To deny the Eternal Sonship is not unheard of in the realms of Christian theological discussion as the late Dr. Walter Martin did this as well, but in my case, I was readily labeled a heretic because I also questioned the words persons (or core individualities, or minds) and instead preferred, the simple name, before the incarnation, of God alone – and nothing more.
Understand, I believe and admit that God, His Word and His Spirit have all existed from eternity, that they are co-equal, and that they are uncreated. But I have major arguments with the man-made characterization (or what we might call the personification) of either the Word or Spirit being called separate and distinct “persons.”
Rejecting the word “person” commonly used by Christians to describe the three who composes the Trinity goes a long way to avoid the confusion of dividing God up. Like the Trinitarians quixotically admit, He is One. To describe them as co-eternally three separate persons automatically refutes this claim. And God becomes absolutely non-sensical. Oh, I know, people love to say things like, “well, if we humans could understand the make-up of an eternal God, He wouldn’t be worthy of our worship.” Really? It seems to me that the living God desires for those who love and seek Him to know Him in spirit and truth, and that He desires His children to see Him with Spiritual eyes rather than through the lens of man-made tradition.
Also, while I readily acknowledge the existence of “three” in the pre-creation period as fully and eternally present and agree with the Trinitarian notion that they are all of or from the one God (in substance) I do firmly believe this God-substance is best understood as fire, light and spirit and am convinced the oneness of God is best understood by these characteristics and not separate persons.
This view has been criticized by some because (for them) it smacks of what they call Modalism – which, depending on the form of Modalism - describes ONE God who manifests Himself in three different ways.
Traditional Modalism – also known as Sabellianism – says that God could not be in more than one place at one time, therefore the Father became the Son and then after the ascension the Son became the Holy Spirit. I reject this view as much as I reject the Trinity. Sadly, most “modalists” reject the deity of Christ – and nothing could be further from my mind and heart. (see, Don’t F**K with Jesus).
So, while I wholly sustain and accept all verses of scripture that describe our human King in ways like Matthew 1:23, which says,
“Behold, a virgin shall be with child, and shall bring forth a son, and they shall call his name Emmanuel, which being interpreted is, God with us.”
When the virgin was with child and brought forth a Son, whose name was Emmanuel and means, “God with us” do I also believe that God (the Father) was looking “down from on high” so to speak? Absolutely. And that the Holy Spirit was also simultaneously at work as God on earth testifying of His Son? Yes!
But we are still left with some issues that cannot be reconciled by embracing the man-made myth called the Trinity nor the orthodox descriptions of it. After coming out of Mormonism, instead of reading what men say about the nature of God I decided to study the Bible itself. And what has my reading of the Bible (hopefully in conjunction with the Holy Spirit) led to?
First, as mentioned, there is the problem of Eternal Sonship. And I came to reject the teaching that the man/person named Jesus of Nazareth was “a separate and distinct person from the Father for all eternity.” No way. What BECAME God’s only human Son and was named Jesus of Nazareth was God’s logos or Word which came from Him and by which He created all things. Period.
Now admittedly, I’ve no idea how God’s logos and pneuma operated. I mean, God is Spirit, and God is a consuming fire, and God is love – right? How He speaks or breathes is incomprehensible to us (since He is spirit) so I am not suggesting that we are capable of such understanding at this juncture. But to create three persons to make up the One God is way too convenient but more importantly, is not contextually supported by Holy writ.
Orthodox Trinitarianism refers to the three co-equal uncreated persons by titles given them at the incarnation (Father, Son, and the Holy Spirit) but this does not mean they are eternally separate or distinct persons – even if the Greek (used in that day) appears to support the notion in certain places (remember, scripture was written after the fact, so it would be natural for writers to speak of the person they knew (meaning Jesus by name specifically) as always existing. Admittedly, once YHWH’s Word was made flesh, those titles were absolutely biblical and apropos. But pre-creation?
While Theos is certainly eternal, and His Word, and His Spirit are equally eternal, I reject the titles Father, Son, and Holy Spirit as eternally applicable because the Old Testament never identifies them by these titles unless we are speaking prophetically or representationally (meaning, not literally). And even then, the title of Father only exists in few places.
However, the prevailing and over emphasized monotheistic views which are repeatedly found in the Old Testament lead me to view God as manifesting Himself (in His relation to the salvation of human kind) in flesh and blood and by the indwelling of His Spirit far more than thinking three separate and distinct persons existed pre-creation.
I am not suggesting, for instance, that the burning bush was God (meaning the bush itself) but I am saying that at that point in His work among fallen Man this was one way God represented Himself – as fire that did not consume.
Additionally, I am also not suggesting that the burning bush was on the same level of His manifestations as Emmanuel or the Holy Spirit falling or indwelling because in the end, the (spirit) pneuma and the Word (made flesh) are “as much God” as the Father. But again, how this was is a mystery we cannot explain - yet. But what we can do is appeal to scripture for as much insight as possible. Which is what we will do from this point forward.
Speaking of reprobate, fallen humanity, and what they do with God, Paul writes in Romans 1:22-23:
22 Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools (Listen) and changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to (1) corruptible man, and (2) to birds, and (3) fourfooted beasts, and (4) creeping things.
The glory of God is not anything like “corruptible man” (and bottom-line, when we say “persons” we cannot help but think “man”) or “birds, four-footed beasts, or creeping things” – of this Paul is clear. But scripture does say a few things relative to the make-up or ontology of God upon which we can rely because it is by and through the study of scripture that we come to identify or see the pre-creation ontology of Him. And the scripture gives us some very strong statements about Him and His makeup, like the following quips, that say
- God IS a consuming fire
- God IS light
- God IS love
- God IS spirit
I personally (still and ardently) maintain that the best way to understand pre-creation Theos, Logos, and Pneuma – which are all manifestations of the monotheist God – is fire - not fire that burns like a campfire, converting material into heated energy, but fire that burns clear and clean and without the need to consume any other matter to exist.
Scripture also says that God is Light, which goes hand in hand with our understanding of fire – an attribute Jesus assigns to Himself in John 8:12.
I am not going to cover the third description of Him being love – which is a characteristic rather than a physical description and one we’ll save that for another time – but for the time being let’s just stick with the biblical descriptions of God “as a consuming fire,” and “light.”
1st John 1:5 says
“This then is the message which we have heard of him, and declare unto you, that God is light, and in him is no darkness at all.”
I would suggest that “no darkness” means not only the absence of physical darkness . . . but also of any spiritual darkness, including
Guile
Ignorance
Lies
Hypocrisy (Jesus despised the darkness of hypocrisy)
Shadow
Trickery
Death
Deception
Blindness
God knows all that He wants to know – a stance which somewhat rejects another man-made concept of God being Omniscient. He knows what He chooses to know – which leaves Him with the option to know everything – again, if and when He chooses.
The thinking then, and for me at least, is that if scripture plainly says God is Light, and if Jesus is God, then the syllogism must be Jesus is light, and His words in the temple (that we mentioned above) are true. And by His own admission, “He is the Light of the World.”
Then, 1st John 4:8 says “God is love.”
Since God is love, and Jesus is God with us, then Jesus must be love, which we see manifested throughout His incarnation. Finally, and relative to our topic of the ontology of God, Hebrews 12:29 says “for our God is a consuming fire.”
Again, since God is a consuming fire, and Jesus is God with us, then what was in Jesus (not in His flesh) was a consuming fire. His flesh was not. And all of this brings us back to Jesus standing there in the temple and saying point blank:
“I am the light of the world.”
I don’t think there is enough time in a month to fully flesh this verse out in a contextual and biblically sound manner it is SO rife with meaning. But we will give it a go in the next few pages anyway.
Let me appeal to three sets of passages of scripture to set the stage – Genesis 1:1-5, John 1:1-3 and 1st John 1:1-3.
Genesis 1:1-5 says:
1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth. 2 And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters. 3 And God said, Let there be light: and there was light. 4 And God saw the light, that it was good: and God divided the light from the darkness. 5 And God called the light Day, and the darkness he called Night. And the evening and the morning were the first day.
Then let’s read from the Gospel of John, those all-familiar verses in chapter 1:1-5:
John 1:1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. 2 The same was in the beginning with God. 3 All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made. 4 In him was life; and the life was the light of men. 5 And the light shineth in darkness; and the darkness comprehended it not.
Finally, John the Beloved gives some more personal witness of the divinity of Christ in his epistle 1st John, saying:
1st John 1:1 That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon, and our hands have handled, of the Word of life; 2 (For the life was manifested, and we have seen it, and bear witness, and shew unto you that eternal life, which was with the Father, and was manifested unto us;) 3 That which we have seen and heard declare we unto you, that ye also may have fellowship with us: and truly our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ.
Now, go back with me to the Genesis one verses which I am going to use to prove my perspective. We know something very important from the narrative of the Apostolic Record – that from the foundation of the World God had His plan of victory in place. By and through what?
Light – which became incarnate and dwelled among us as Jesus of Nazareth. Matthew 13:35 talks about the Messiah coming and that he would open “His mouth in parables; uttering things which have been kept secret from the foundation of the world.”
John 17:24 has Jesus praying and (speaking of His disciples) saying:
“Father, I will that they also, whom thou hast given me, be with me where I am; that they may behold my glory, which thou hast given me: for thou lovedst me before the foundation of the world.”
Speaking of Jesus since ascended Peter says in 1st Peter 1:20:
“Who verily was foreordained before the foundation of the world, but was manifest in these last times for you.”
Then of course Revelation says in 13:8:
“And all that dwell upon the earth shall worship him, whose names are not written in the book of life of the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world.”
So, what is this about the foundation of the world, with the Lamb being slain then? Do we have any insight to this event at all? We do. And it is fascinating. Go back with me to the very first verses of the Bible. Here we read a number of things that are often misunderstood so let’s read them together as Moses, in what I believe is a summary (or preamble) to all he is about to write thereafter, wrote the first verse of the Bible and says:
1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.
In other words, I think (and of course, I could be wrong) but I think Moses is saying:
“In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth and here are some insights to it . . .
Where it says “God” the Hebrew is elohiym, and it is plural. I would suggest that the better understanding of this is that God is acting by and through His Spirit and through His Word spoken. In verse two I would suggest that Moses now provides a very abbreviated description of creation, saying:
2 And the earth was without form, and void; and darkness was upon the face of the deep. And the Spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters.
The Hebrew word for darkness here in the second verse of the Bible is “khoshek” and for the most part, throughout the Old Testament, this term (translated darkness in the English) describes some form or expression of evil. It can describe physical darkness, but it more often than not describes destruction, misery, and the general opposite of light. In fact, Strong’s Bible Interlinear says this of the word:
Literal - darkness; figuratively - misery, destruction, death, ignorance, sorrow, wickedness:--dark(-ness), night, obscurity.
Many people, without really looking at context interpret the term darkness here in verse 2 as literal darkness – like an environment without sunlight or stars. And this kind of makes sense since God is about to create everything so it seems the entire space void would be physically dark. But I would strongly, strongly suggest that this darkness is figuratively speaking, and that evil, destruction, ignorance, sorrow and wickedness was upon the face of the deep – and not just physical darkness.
Prior to doing any creating and prior to anything being formed, we read the third verse which is God’s response to this darkness. And these are the first words God speaks in the Bible:
3 And God said, “Let there be light: and there was light.”
A couple of things about verse three. First of all, it is not speaking of God creating the Sun that hangs in our sky or the stars or moons or planets to give physical rays to the universe or earth. He speaks these things into existence later (on the fourth day which is described in verses 14-16) where it says:
“And God said, Let there be lights in the firmament of the heaven to divide the day from the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, and for days, and years: And let them be for lights in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth: and it was so. And God made two great lights; the greater light to rule the day, and the lesser light to rule the night: he made the stars also. And God set them in the firmament of the heaven to give light upon the earth, and to rule over the day and over the night, and to divide the light from the darkness: and God saw that it was good. And the evening and the morning were the fourth day.”
So, here in the very beginning we are reading about the first day (which, by the way, proves that these days could not be twenty-four hour periods since God calls what He is doing here the first day . . . but the sun and stars are not created until the fourth (anyway, that’s for another book as well).
But what was God was talking about when He said in verse 3 “Let there be light.”
The Hebrew word translated light is “RWA” and it not only means light, but also fire. In the face of the darkness God could be paraphrased as saying, “before doing anything else, let me manage this darkness, and He said, let there be light.”
This gives some real significance to Jesus words in John 8 as He stood in the temple and said:
“I am the Light of the World.” It also helps us understand why the Pharisees standing there were not overwrought with anger over it.
Referring again to Bible scholar Schoettgen, a number of Jewish Rabbin’s believe that Genesis 1:3 was in reference to the promised Messiah. Now this is going to get a little heavy but hang with me.
God the Father manifesting in flesh or Spirit are uncreated and self-existing. Knowing that the Word was not a created thing, but was “with the Father from the beginning,” co-eternal and co-equal, so to speak, I think we can see that “In the Beginning,” when God (plural) said
“Let there be light,”
. . . that the “Word of God,” self-existing, was offered up (listen) as the light of the world from before the foundation of the World! I know this is really heavy, and I’m not sure we can ever get our minds around it. But in and through it we agree that the Word (of God) created all things, that the Word spoke light into place (before the foundations of the world) as a means to confound (or to have victory over the darkness), and we are able to see how Jesus, the incarnate Word, was able to plainly refer to Himself as I AM – the self-existent one. Because “the Word was with God and the Word was God!”
So again, from before the foundation of the world, God said (words), in the face of the DARKNESS,
“Let there be light,” and here, from the foundation of the World, God’s solution – light, which was come into the world thousands of years later in the form of a man, was given. Notice that God did not say,
“Let there be my Son.”
The first thing He said (and I’m going to paraphrase so please forgive me) was
“Let there be light to come in, offset and overwhelm the darkness, and have victory from the foundations of the world.”
In other words, “In the face of such darkness, God said, I am going to first establish victory – light – my light, to overcome the darkness and I’ll do it by speaking WORDS.
3 And God said, Let there be light: and there was light.
To me, when God said, “Let there be light,” He was saying, “Before I create anything I am going to establish the solution to all this misery and darkness before me and I will bring light in the face of it all . . . my light . . . my fire.” And He did this by His Word. But the real clincher to it all is located in verse five, which says:
“And God called the light Day, and the darkness he called Night. And the evening and the morning were the first day.”
Notice the capitalization here of “Day” and “Night.” What is that about? I propose that this naming of the “light” Day is the naming of the “Light of the World Day” (with a capital D) and it is the naming of the darkness of the world, Night (with a capital N). In other words, pre-incarnate Jesus, the pre-creation “Word” was, from the foundation of the World, called Day (again, not Son) as He is the light of the world, or the Day Star. This is a highly symbolic, metaphorically driven language – but it is not limited to Genesis one.
In 2nd Peter 1:19 we read:
“We have also a more sure word of prophecy; whereunto ye do well that ye take heed, as unto a light that shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the “day star” arise in your hearts.”
Where Peter says, “And the day-star arise in your hearts,” this is speaking of Christ and is better translated as the morning star. I consulted twelve translations of this verse and ten of the twelve translate “Day Star” as “Morning Star.”
So, who, again, is Christ but “a light, a fire, the Day Star, (with a capital D) and the Morning Star.
2nd Corinthians 4:3-6 says:
“But if our gospel be hid, it is hid to them that are lost: in whom the god of this world hath blinded the minds of them which believe not, lest the light of the glorious gospel of Christ, who is the image of God, should shine unto them. For we preach not ourselves, but Christ Jesus the Lord; and ourselves your servants for Jesus' sake. For God, who commanded the light to shine out of darkness, hath shined in our hearts, to give the light of the knowledge of the glory of God in the face of Jesus Christ.”
Speaking of Himself, Jesus says in Revelation 22:16:
“I Jesus have sent mine angel to testify unto you these things in the churches. I am the root and the offspring of David, and the bright and morning star.”
For these reasons, and from before the foundations of the World, in the face of the darkness, God said, “Let there be light,” and then “and the evening and the morning were the first Day.” Did you catch it? The evening and the morning were the FIRST Day - the Alpha and the Omega. Not some second-damn-person-of-the-man-made-fiction called the Trinity.
We have been talking a lot about the man-made word Trinity which I (painfully) discovered is quite a sacred term to many believing Christians. And as mentioned, one of the major issues I have had with the definition of the term is regarding what our theologians have labeled as “eternal Sonship.”
Again, what this means is that in the pre-creative period – meaning before the beginning – Trinitarians say, that God existed in three separate persons called, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit and that these three persons make up the One being called God.
This relationship between the father and the Son was described to me (by one of the world’s foremost experts on the subject of the Trinity) as “reflected in the relationship that exists between an earthly human father and an earthly son.” I personally have issue with this description not only from how I have long understood God to be but from how I believe God is described in the Bible – particularly the Old Testament - relative to Eternal Sonship. So, this brings us to a passage in the Word that I find quite intriguing. Ready? It’s found in Hebrews 13:8 and says,
“Jesus Christ the same yesterday, and to day, and for ever.”
Now ask yourself, is Jesus Christ “the same yesterday, to-day and forever?” I trust the scripture so I believe that He must be, but are we interpreting what this means correctly?
I believe that almost any Christian on earth would agree that the writer of Hebrews is speaking of the LOGOS of God that was made flesh being the same eternally but would also have to admit that His flesh certainly changed. In light of this passage, it’s important to make note of a couple of things:
First, Jesus Christ did not become “Jesus” until (the Word of God which does not change) was made flesh. Only then was the Word of God given the name Jesus of Nazareth. From this we know the writer of Hebrews uses the name Jesus to describe the Word of God (which does not change) and not the Man (who did).
In other words, if Jesus Christ the “person” was from the foundation of the world, then this passage could not be true because He became flesh . . . and therefore changed . . . and therefore is NOT the same yesterday, today and forever. Get it?
The Word became flesh, was given the name Yeshua at that time, but that Man is NOT whom the writer of Hebrews is saying is ”the same yesterday, to day, and forever” – only what was in that Man. Which is the one God’s Word. Additionally, I would suggest we have to take this passage out even further. I believe it is ONLY speaking of Jesus the Christ, the Light of the World and not Jesus, Son of Mary and Joseph.
What I mean by this is Jesus the Son of Mary and Joseph was not the “same yesterday, to day and forever” He was maturing and changing and growing as Jesus, Son of Joseph and Mary, since birth. This distinction is important, and it is why Luke wrote in Luke 2:52:
“And Jesus increased in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and man.”
So again, this passage in Hebrews is talking about pre-incarnate Word of God not about a person known as Jesus when He became flesh and then, I would suggest it is also but only speaking of Jesus (the Man from Nazareth) once He overcame sin, and death, and the grave.
Why care or even make the distinction? Because it's true and we seek to worship God in Spirit and in Truth. And by making these distinctions we come to an understanding of God and His Son that transcends religious rhetoric heaped upon us by tradition. The admission does not take away from Him as our Savior, God and King – in fact, in my opinion, it highlights what He actually did on our behalf. God became a man, suffered as a man, and God overcame the weakness of that man’s flesh, making Him truly His only begotten Son.
The distinction is also important because it is speaking of His humanity which did not establish itself as God (who is the same yesterday, today and forever) until after His resurrection from the grave. In other words, prior to His resurrection Jesus was tempted, Jesus was not privy to all things, and Jesus suffered death – things were cannot be described as “the same yesterday, to day, and forever.”
The point is (which we often lose in today’s fervent Jesus movements) God’s literal Word of Light and Fire and what created all things somehow became human and taking on flesh overcame all things for us. This incarnation, meaning the fleshly home, was not God! Not before His resurrection. So, to read, “Jesus Christ is the same yesterday, today and forever” and to mindlessly believe it is referring to the Man born of a woman removes the utter and complete humility, sacrifice, and suffering God endured, as man, to save us from ourselves.
So that is God relative to His Word that became His only human son by birth. The flesh was God and Mary’s beloved son, what was in that son, at His incarnation, was the One God’s Word/Seed and not a separate and distinct co-equal person.
Now let’s talk about the Holy Spirit, which is defined by Trinitarian logic as the third person of the One God.
Jesus says something important to His apostles in John chapter 15:26-27 where we read: (listen closely)
26 But when the Comforter is come, whom I will send unto you from the Father, even the Spirit of truth, which proceedeth from the Father, he shall testify of me.
From this passage we learn a few things. First, we learn that Jesus describes the Holy Spirit (or the Comforter) as proceeding from the Father, who is God. Not from the presence of God, but from God Himself. “Issued forth from” is a better way to read it, just like the logos which proceeded forth from God and then became flesh in the human Son Jesus Christ.
We will examine the Holy Spirit more closely in our next book, Don’t F**K with the Spirit but if you are interested in looking more deeply into the Trinity, you might consider checking out the following:
James H. Broughton and Peter J. Southgate (The Trinity: True or False? 1995), Anthony Buzzard (The Doctrine of the Trinity; Christianity’s Self-Inflicted Wound, 1994), Charles Morgridge (The True Believer’s Defense, 1837), Fredric A. Farley (The Scripture Doctrine of the Father, Son and Holy Ghost, 1873) and The Racovian Catechism of 1609. And also a guy named, Brother Kel on YouTube. He’s got the falsehood of the Trinity down.
But relative to the Trinity and the Holy Spirit, here are some things to consider, namely these 24 simple points:
1. The Holy Spirit is the Spirit of God, not a separate person.
2. Although the Hebrew word for “spirit” (ruach), can refer to angels or evil spirits, which are persons or entities with a personality, the Hebrew usage of “the spirit of God” never refers to a person separate from, but a part of, God Almighty.
3. The phrase, “the spirits of God” never occurs because it would refer to separate spiritual entities within a multi-personal God. There is only the Spirit of God. If God is a Spirit person, and the Holy Spirit is a separate spirit person from the Father, then spirits of God would be a norm.
4. As with the Hebrew word, ruach, the Greek word for spirit (pneuma) also has many different meanings, and the correct one is determinable only from the context of each occurrence. So, while Greek has both upper and lower case letters, the early manuscripts employed either one or the other. Therefore, no accurate distinction can be made in the oldest manuscripts of the Bible between upper case “Holy Spirit,” (which is a proper noun referring to God) and a lower case “holy spirit,” which would refer to an impersonal force. Compounding the problem is the fact that the article “the” was often added by translators, leading the reader to think that “the Holy Spirit” is referring to a separate person or the third person of “the Holy Trinity.”
5. Like the issues with eternal Sonship existing in the Old Testament, most scholars admit that the concept of the Trinity cannot be substantiated in the Old Testament. Particularly, “the Holy Spirit” does not have any kind of independent or distinct place in Old Testament writings. It is the force or power of God.
6. With the exception of a few comparatively difficult verses in the Gospel of John, the Apostolic Record also gives no certain or incontrovertible indication of a “Holy Spirit” as a personal being co-equal with the Father and the Son. I would strongly suggest that it therefore makes sense to understand “holy spirit” in the New Testament just as it was understood in the Old Testament, either as “the spirit of God Himself” (or His presence and power) and not ever a separate person.
7. The Greek word for “spirit,” pneuma, is neuteral, as are all pronouns referring to the spirit, making them necessarily impersonal. New Testament translators knew this grammatically, but groundlessly translated references to the coming “spirit of truth” as “He” instead of “it” due to their Trinitarian prejudice. An example of this is John 14:17 which says:
John 14:17 “Even the Spirit of truth; whom the world cannot receive, because it seeth (him) not, neither knoweth (him): but ye know (him); for (he) dwelleth with you, and shall be in you.”
If the translators had consistently translated the neuter pronouns of John 14 through 16 as “it,” “its,” “itself” and “which” instead of “he,” “his,” “him,” “who,” and “whom,” the case for the “personality of the Holy Spirit” would largely disappear from Christian belief.
8. In John 14 Jesus refers to the Holy Spirit as “the Comforter and that the comforter, in this singular case, is called a “he.”
Any translation from one language to another must recognize the relative unimportance of gender. For the most part, languages that assign a gender to nouns do so in a rather arbitrary manner. For instance, the Spanish word for car is masculine, el carro, while a bicycle is feminine, la bicicleta. Yet no one would translate into English “the car, he…” or “the bicycle, she….” Either word would require the neuter “it” to reflect the impersonal nature of the object.
A writer or a poet might employ such a figurative expression in the use of pronouns to personify things, but any reader acquainted with the objects referred to would recognize the figure of speech employed. This is what happened when the poetic personification was employed in reference to “the Comforter,” and it became a “He.” Additionally, speech personification is common in scripture, and is defined as attributing personal qualities, feelings, actions, etc., to things that have no real personality or personal consciousness.
For example, “wisdom” is personified as such in Proverbs 8 and 9, yet no sensible person would seriously believe that a literal person named “Wisdom” helped God create the world, as Proverbs 8:30 says. Likewise, the spirit of God is personified as “the Comforter” in John 14:16 and 26, 15:26, 16:7. Therefore, personal pronouns are appropriate to agree with the personal nature of the figurative title. It is clear from John 16:13 that this Comforter is “sent,” “does not speak of himself” and is instructed (“whatever it hears it speaks”).
Also, the “Comforter,” (more properly translated as “Counselor,”) is said by Jesus to fill the void created by His going to the Father (John 14:12). We also know that by this spirit Jesus would still be present with them as He said, “I will come to you” (John 14:18); “I am in you” (in 14:20); and “I will show myself” (in 14:21). By this spirit (it) his work with them would continue, as Jesus said: “It will teach you” (14:26); “It will remind you of everything I have said” (14:26); “It will testify about me” (15:26); “It will convict the world of guilt” (in preparation for his judgment—16:8); “It will guide you into all truth” (16:13); and “It will bring glory to me by taking what is mine and making it known to you” (16:14). Not He – it.
All of these statements point to the role of the gift of holy spirit in continuing the work that Jesus started, to the point of even empowering his followers to produce greater works. This spirit is not independent and self-existent but is “the mind of Christ” within the believer, influencing, guiding, teaching, reminding and pointing the believer to follow the Lord and Savior.
This spirit is certainly not “co-equal” when by its very design it serves the risen Lord and Christ to bring people to the living God. But the use of personification is appropriate because it carries the personal presence of Christ into the life of every believer that receives it.
Practically speaking, the holy spirit in us will not lead us anywhere or cause us to do anything that the Lord himself would not do if he were personally present. That is its power.
Remember that the Greek word pneuma (translated “spirit”) is never capitalized. It is always in a lower case. So, when it appears in any Bible translation as a capital “S” that has been at the prerogative of the bible translators and not from the mss text. I mention this because capitalizing the “H” in Holy and the “S” in Spirit has helped people believe that the Holy Spirit is a person or separate co-equal being to God the Father.
Specifically, then, what exactly is the Holy Spirit? It is a gift from God.
Listen – God is Holy (hagios) and God is Spirit (pneuma). Hagias Pneuma (God) is the giver of this gift of his hagias pneuma (lower case). We cannot confuse the giver of the gift (God) with the gift He gives! That’s like confusing created things in nature with the Creator of those things! Not good.
9. Every individual has a spirit within them. The Bible uses the term soul (psuche) and spirit (pneuma or ruach) in distinct ways and also synonymously to describe them. For instance, in Psalm 42:5 we read:
“Why art thou cast down, O my soul?” (Ps. 42:5).
And in Matthew 26:41 Jesus said of His sleeping disciples:
“The spirit indeed is willing but the flesh is weak.”
I would suggest that the spirit of a Man has the same relation to the man that the spirit of God has to God.
1st Corinthians 2:10-11 says clearly:
“But God hath revealed them unto us by his Spirit: for the Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God. For what man knoweth the things of a man, save the spirit of man which is in him? even so the things of God knoweth no man, but the Spirit of God.”
I would suggest that as the spirit of man is not another person distinct from the individual person, it is instead himself and is indistinguishable from the person who possesses it - so is the Spirit of God not another person distinct from God. His Spirit is his spirit.
As the spirit of man literally means the man himself (the essence of a man is his mind), so the spirit of God means God Himself – with His essence being Spirit. Isaiah 40:13 asks:
“Who hath directed the Spirit of the LORD, or being his counsellor hath taught him?” Was Isaiah speaking of the Lord YHWH or a separate spirit person? In what I believe might be a parallel verse Paul said in Romans 11:34
Romans 11:34 For who hath known the mind of the Lord? or who hath been his counsellor?
I wonder if just as the mind of man is not His fleshly body but his spirit/soul if the Holy Spirit of God is the same – the mind or spirit/soul of God?
10. In John 14:17 we read about the “spirit of truth.” The King James gives the s (in the Spirit of Truth) a capital making Him (for Trinitarians a person, the third person of the Godhead). In that verse the Greek for spirit of Truth is simply “pneuma alathea” which I believe is the spirit of God non persona.
I say this because in 1st John 4:6 John again writes of “the spirit of truth” (pneuma alathea) with a lower case s and in the same line refers to “the spirit of error,” (pneuma plane – which is also a lower case s). My point is if the Spirit of Truth is an actual person then so is the Spirit of Error – but this is simply not the case – each of these “spirits” represents an influence or a power under which a person acts, but neither is a person acting independently and of itself.
11. 1st Corinthians 2:12 directly contrasts the “spirit of the world” with “the spirit which is of God.” As the “spirit of the world” is not a person separate from “the world,” neither is the “spirit of God” a person separate from God. Each is the power or influence coming out from the source of origin – either God or the world – and again, are not persons.
12. We know that the breath of God and the Spirit of God are used synonymously. Admittedly, with God it is certainly possible that his breath takes on the form of separate person (similar to the Word becoming flesh) but to me God’s breath and words are all Him – manifestations of Him – relating and interacting with humanity.
13. It makes no sense to call the Holy Spirit an uncreated person and at the same time the breath of God – how could God’s breath be an uncreated person?
14. Likewise, it seems crazy to call a “co-equal and co-eternal person” the “hand” and finger” of God as scripture does. In fact, if we think about it, the hand and finger of a man is subordinate to a man, doing what the man wants, not what the finger wants. God sends His Spirit to do His will like a man uses his finger to pick up something according to his will – same premise.
15. In scripture, the “spirit of your Father,” is synonymous with “the holy spirit,” and is said to speak in our stead on certain occasions when we might be standing before men on trial or whatever. For example, in Luke 21:15 we read that Christ will give us “a mouth and wisdom, which all your adversaries shall not be able to gainsay nor resist.” We notice that Luke does not write that a person called “the Holy Ghost” will speak through us but that we will be inspired by the supernatural power of God and Christ to speak as they desire.
16. Trinitarians claim that the spirit is sentient (able to sense), self-aware, separate, and a distinct being with its own personality (since he is a male being or person of some type). I’m not sure Jesus understood this take when He said in Matthew 11:27
“No “man” (Holy Spirit included) knoweth the Son, but the Father; neither knoweth any man the Father, save the Son.”
If “the Holy Spirit” is a male (he) person distinct from the Father, and is also omniscient and almighty, then why didn’ Jesus include Him in the mix of Matthew 11?
And again, in Matthew 24:36, Jesus says that no “one” (no person) knew the hour of his Second Coming except the Father. How could the Trinitarian person of the Holy Spirit be kept in the dark about this very important prophetic event and why doesn’t Jesus mention this here? Are we supposed to believe that it is possible for one member of the Godhead to keep a secret from another member while at the same time sharing the same eternal and divine “essence” of being God Almighty coeternal and uncreated and co equal? The excuses that people come up to respond to these simple observations are confirmational biases they use to make their doctrines make sense.
I trust the Bible. If Jesus says, No one but the Father knows the hour I believe it. And if someone suggests that the Father keeps this secret from the co-equal person of the Holy Spirit, I cry foul. Listen - if “God” is three co-equal “persons,” as the Trinitarians claim, the third person can no more be “the spirit” of the first person, than the first person can be “the spirit” of the third person. To avoid such an absurdity, we must admit that “the spirit of God” cannot have a separate personality, but must be the power, influence, sufficiency, fullness or some extension of the Father who is the One True God.
17. 1st John 4:13 says
“We know that we live in Him and He in us, because he has given us of his Spirit.”
God took the spirit that was on Moses and put it on the seventy elders of Israel. Joel prophesied that God would pour out “a part or some of His Spirit” on the day of Pentecost - which He did. But the point is the spirit of God is divisible and can be portioned out. This makes sense when we view the Spirit of God as His breath, coming from Him and NOT a person, personage, or being.
18. The Bible purposefully uses very figurative language for the Holy Spirit to show that it is the invisible power and influence of God. God sends His spirit to come into our lives to comfort us, help us, teach us, and bring us to Christ. Scripture purposefully uses imagery like liquid and wind to describe the Spirit of God, saying:
We are baptized (literally “dipped”) with and in it like water (Matthew 3:11).
We are all made to “drink” from the same spirit, as from a well or fountain (1 Corinthians 12:13).
It is written on our hearts like ink (2 Corinthians 3:3).
We are “anointed” with it, like oil (2nd Corinthians 1:21-22).
We are “sealed” with it as with melted wax (Ephesians 1:13).
It is “poured out” on us (Acts 10:45, Romans 5:5).
It is “measured” as if it had volume (2 Kings 2:9 and John 3:34).
We are to be “filled” with it (Acts 2:4; Ephesians 5:18) and this “filling” is to capacity at the new birth and to overflowing as we act according to its influence.
Even the use of spirit as “wind” implies a liquidity, for air masses behave as a fluid, flowing from areas of higher to lower pressures. None of this describes a person. By definition, the spirit of God is derived from God. What comes from God as its source cannot also be “God,” without the term “God” being reduced to a formless and incomprehensible abstraction. Nothing and no one can be both a source of a thing and the thing itself. There is a great difference between the Giver and the Gift he is giving. Seeing God as the Father with expressions of himself in spirit and truth erases all of this f**kery.
19. The Bible synonymously uses “the term Holy Spirit” with “God.” In Acts 5:3, Peter says Ananias lied to “the Holy Spirit,” then in verse 4 Peter says he lied to “God.”
This is an example of the common Semitic parallelism of equivalent terms and is not evidence that Ananias lied to two separate persons. If that were the case, why would verse 4 not say that Ananias lied to “the Father” instead of to “God?” Nor is this parallelism evidence that another divine person called “the Holy Spirit” is also “God” and therefore part of a triune “Godhead” as Trinitarians interpret it.
20. (this is a big one) We say that Jesus is the Son of God. But Luke says that He was conceived of the “holy spirit.” If the Holy Spirit is a separate person, then wouldn’t Jesus be the Son of the Holy Spirit and not the Son of God? But, if the Holy Spirit is simply “the power of the Most High,” as Luke 1:35 clearly indicates, we can see what the Holy Spirit is . . . (the power of God) and not (a separate person of a Trinity).
Trinitarianism leads to far too much unnecessary confusion with its assertions of “the Holy Spirit” being a separate person, personality, or being, when it is merely God’s power interacting with Man to teach and guide.
21. Additionally, but not the most clear point we can make, the “Holy spirit” is used synonymously and interchangeably with
“the spirit of Jesus” (Acts 16:7; Philippians 1:19)
“the spirit of the Lord” (Luke 4:18)
“the spirit of his son” (Galatians 4:6);
“the spirit of Jesus Christ” (Philippians 1:19).
In these examples, “the spirit” is described as the mind and power of Jesus Christ, who fills and guides believers to do the will of God, his Father. With Christ as our mediator this makes great sense. And with this in mind look how there is a clear relationship and interdependence between the Lord Jesus Christ and his “spirit.”
Later in Acts 16:6, in the midst of the work Paul was called to do, “the Holy Spirit” kept Paul and his companions from preaching in Asia. Then in the next verse we read that the “spirit of Jesus” would not allow them to enter Bithynia. They are one and the same! But to make the holy spirit a person we only arrive at confusion.
2 Corinthians 3:17 and 18 says that the Lord (Jesus) is “the Spirit.” He has been invested with all spiritual authority and power to effectively carry out his responsibility as the Head of his body. By his “spirit” he is able to guide and direct his many servants (2nd Corinthians 12:8 and 9).
Galatians 5:22 and 23 list the “fruit of the spirit” (which is the nature of Jesus Christ) coinciding with John 15:5 which says “If a man remains in me and I in him, he will bear much fruit.”
2nd Thessalonians 2:13) says we are sanctified by the spirit and 1st Corinthians 1:2 says we are sanctified in Christ Jesus (1 Corinthians 1:2), whom God made to be sanctification for us (1 Corinthians 1:30).
We know that scripture calls the spirit of truth (the holy spirit) (parakletos) and then speaking of Jesus it says we have an advocate (parakletos) with the Father (1st John 2:1).
Again, we are strengthened by the spirit in the inner man (Ephesians 3:16) and the next verse says it is “Christ that dwells in our hearts.” (Ephesians 3:17).
Ephesians 2:18 says “We have access to the Father by the spirit” and then Ephesians 3:12 says “in Christ and through faith in him we have access with confidence to God.”
Romans 8:26 says, “The spirit intercedes for us,” Romans 8:34 says “Christ Jesus intercedes for us.”
From the “mouth” of God came His Word. From the “mouth” of God comes His breath. God is One, folks, the giver of all of these things – word, breath, spirit, fire, life, light, Christ – they are all synonymous. And the One God so loved the world He gifted us with His Son, the Word made flesh and then as a means to draw all men to His Son, He then gifted us with His hagias pneuma, His very spirit which is holy.
Not a person but a gift the Giver gives to the world He so loves.
22. The only verse that would indicate that there might be three persons sharing one name is Matthew 28:19 which has Jesus saying:
“Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost.”
But this verse is quoted in a different form by the early Church Fathers, notably Eusebius (340 AD), who quotes the verse at least 18 times as follows: “baptizing them in my name.” This rendering agrees with the testimony of the Book of Acts and Paul’s epistles, which associate only the name of Jesus Christ with baptism as no apostle is recorded as baptizing anyone in the way Jesus supposedly tells them to do at the great commission. But even if the verse reads as it is found in modern versions today, it does not, in my opinion, validate the “Holy Spirit” being a separate person from God.
23. The Holy Spirit is never worshiped as the Father and the Son. No verse of Scripture commands such worship of the holy spirit. I think this is quite surprising if the Holy Spirit is truly a co-equal and co-eternal member of a triune “God” worthy of worship. In other words, if “God” is worthy of worship, and “God” exists in three persons, then shouldn’t each “God-person” be worthy of worship? If so, why isn’t this directive found in the Scripture?
24. Have you ever noticed that in the opening of their New Testament epistles, every one of the writers identifies himself with God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ, but only one of them does so with “the Holy Spirit” too. Why is that? Either they were ignorant of the truth of a “tri-personal” (or Trinitarian God) or they erred and forgot to respectfully include the holy spirit in their introductions. But they didn’t forget. They knew the holy spirit was the gift of God, from God, and not a separate entity or person they needed to mention. And the one apostle who does mention the holy spirit? Peter. This is what he wrote in the introduction of 1st Peter 1:1-2:
“Peter, an apostle of Jesus Christ, to the strangers scattered throughout Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia, Asia, and Bithynia, elect according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, through sanctification of the Spirit, unto obedience and sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ: Grace unto you, and peace, be multiplied.”
But remember, the Spirit ought to be, according to the Greek, a lower case s, not upper to indicate a person. So even Peter was not depicting Trinitarian views here.
And Peter is the only exception. Looking at Paul, in the Church Epistles, (Romans through Thessalonians), when he sends either personal greetings or opens a letter with salutations, it’s always from “God the Father and the Lord Jesus Christ.” Paul NEVER includes the Holy Spirit in any one of the salutations of his epistles to the churches. If “the Holy Spirit” were an integral and personal part of a triune Godhead, then why doesn’t Paul send him personal greetings as well? The only good answer is that Paul was not a Trinitarian. If there were a third person involved, wouldn’t Paul have surely known about it and included “Him” in his greetings to the churches? Interestingly, when Paul actually does include additional persons in his greetings, he names “the elect angels,” but never “the Holy Spirit.”
And how come in Revelation 21-22 the Holy Spirit is not depicted as sitting on a throne like the God Father and His Son are? No throne for it . . . I mean, Him?
Listen . . .
We will never come to a knowledge of the truth nor worship God in Spirit and Truth so long as we have such things wrong in our minds, meaning, as long as we are trying to convince people to worship the One True God and His Son Jesus Christ AND then we add in the holy spirit as a third person to the mix.
In the end, God is one God, not composed of three persons. And the One God spoke all things into existence. And the One God’s eternal words (because they are from Him) became flesh in the Man Jesus of Nazareth, and in Him He overcame all things and Jesus was Deified in flesh as a result. Then the One God sent His Spirit to draw all people to Himself. This spirit is not a separate person, its simply His spirit, just like His words that became flesh are His. And all of it is God.
Consider one last plain passage from Paul who says in 1st Corinthians 8:4-6
As concerning therefore the eating of those things that are offered in sacrifice unto idols, we know that an idol is nothing in the world, and that there is none other God but one. For though there be that are called gods, whether in heaven or in earth, (as there be gods many, and lords many,) But to us there is but one God, the Father, of whom are all things, and we in him; and one Lord Jesus Christ, by whom are all things, and we by him.